Fish and Wildlife Service Lists Five Species of Penguin as Threatened

Yellow-eyed PenguinIn compliance with a settlement agreement previously blogged about here, the Fish and Wildlife Service published a final rule on August 3, 2010 listing five species of penguins as "threatened" under the Endangered Species Act.  Specifically, the Service determined that the yellow-eyed, white-flippered, Fiordland crested, Humboldt, and erect-crested penguins are likely to become in danger of extinction within the foreseeable future.

None of the five species is native to the United States, and therefore no critical habitat is designated for the listed species.  Nevertheless, the listing triggers the requirement that federal agencies evaluate actions they take within the United States or on the high seas for their potential impacts on listed penguins.  The listing also enables the Secretary of the Interior to authorize financial assistance, personnel, and the training of personnel for management and conservation programs for the penguins.

Some contend that anthropogenic climate change is a major threat to the survival of the penguins.  While the Service acknowledged that the evidence of warming of the climate system is unequivocal, it concluded that the best available information does not indicate how increased sea level rise, ocean warming, or ocean acidification may affect the five penguin species.   Instead, the Service determined that other threats such as predation by introduced species, habitat loss, overfishing, unregulated ecotourism, and El Niño events were responsible for the population declines.

Under the terms of the settlement agreement, the Service must issue final rules regarding listing of the African penguin by September 30, 2010, and listing of a distinct population segment of the northern rockhopper penguin by January 28, 2011.

Campaign to Use Endangered Species Act to Regulate Greenhouse Gas Emissions Marches On

American PikaIn an article published in Yale Environment 360 on July 22, 2010, Todd Woody chronicles the ongoing campaign by various environmental organizations to use the Endangered Species Act to compel the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and National Marine Fisheries Service to regulate greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions.

The article, Enlisting Endangered Species As a Tool to Combat Warming, recounts the perils facing the American Pika, previously blogged about here,  to illustrate the broader strategy aimed at forcing the Services to regulate GHG emissions.

As noted in our blog post, Fish and Wildlife Service's to Review Prospect of Listing Whitebark Pine Due to Climate Change, the Service recently announced a 90-day finding that listing the whitebark pine as endangered or threatened due to climate change may be warranted.  In addition, the Fish and Wildlife Service may adopt rules listing several species of penguins due to climate change.  The National Marine Fisheries Service previously determined that a petition to list 83 species of coral due to climate change presented substantial information indicating that listing might be warranted for 82 of the species.  But the Fish and Wildlife Service declined to list the American pika as endangered or threatened due to climate change.

As Mr. Woody notes in his article, these listing decisions have been spurred by petitions and lawsuits filed by several environmental organizations with the aim of not only protecting the species from extinction, but utlimately requiring the Services to require emitters of GHG to reduce or mitigate their emissions.  But, so far, the utimate aim has been frustrated by resistance from both the Bush and Obama Administrations and doubts about the validity of the legal theory underlying the overarching strategy.